By Dr Sophie Newton, NHS GP
Are supplements worth taking after 40? From creatine and collagen to magnesium, omega-3 and ashwagandha, women in their 40s and 50s are being encouraged to take an ever-growing collection of vitamins, minerals and herbal products. But which ones have good evidence behind them, and which might not be worth your money?
As a GP, I get asked about supplements all the time. And I understand why. There's so much conflicting information online that even I sometimes come across a new supplement and wonder whether I've missed something.
The good news is that some supplements genuinely can be useful. I take a few myself. But there's no universal supplement shopping list that every woman needs when she turns 40.
I've looked at 12 popular supplements and divided them into three categories: four worth considering, five where the answer depends on your circumstances, and three I personally wouldn't spend my money on at the moment.
At a glance: Which supplements are worth taking after 40?
My verdictSupplements4 YES: Worth consideringVitamin D, creatine, protein powder, psyllium husk5 MAYBE: Depends on your needsMagnesium, omega-3, iron, turmeric, berberine3 NO: Not convinced they're worth the moneyCollagen for skin, ashwagandha, pumpkin seed oil for hair loss
These aren't universal recommendations. A supplement can be useful for one person and unnecessary for another.
Four supplements I think are worth considering
1. Vitamin D: Particularly important in the UK
Vitamin D helps our bodies absorb calcium and supports healthy bones and muscles.
In the UK, government advice is that adults should consider taking 10 micrograms (400 IU) of vitamin D daily during autumn and winter, when sunlight isn't strong enough for us to make sufficient vitamin D through our skin.
Some people, including those who have little sunlight exposure or are at increased risk of deficiency, should consider supplementation throughout the year.
Vitamin D is inexpensive and widely available. You don't need a premium supplement marketed specifically for menopause.
What about calcium supplements?
Calcium becomes particularly important as we get older because of its role in maintaining bone health.
However, not every woman needs a calcium tablet. Many people can get enough through food, including milk, yoghurt, cheese and calcium-fortified plant milks. Green vegetables also contribute.
If you avoid dairy, have a restricted diet or have osteoporosis, it's worth reviewing your calcium intake and discussing whether supplementation is appropriate.
2. Creatine: Can it help women maintain muscle after 40?
Creatine is one of the supplements I take myself.
For years, it's been associated with bodybuilders and sports performance. But it's increasingly being discussed in relation to healthy ageing, particularly for women in midlife.
As we get older, maintaining muscle mass and strength becomes increasingly important. Resistance training is one of the best things we can do to protect both.
Research suggests that creatine supplementation alongside resistance training can improve strength and muscle gains compared with exercise alone.
There's also emerging research into creatine and brain function, including memory, cognition and the effects of sleep deprivation.
That research is interesting, although we don't yet have convincing evidence that creatine prevents cognitive decline or dementia.
My verdict: Creatine is worth considering, particularly if you're doing regular strength training. It's not a replacement for exercise.
3. Protein powder: Useful if you're struggling to get enough protein
Protein is essential for maintaining muscle, particularly as we get older.
Many women become more conscious of their protein intake in midlife, especially if they're exercising regularly.
Ideally, we should get enough protein through normal food. But that isn't always easy, particularly if you're vegetarian, have a smaller appetite or struggle to include protein-rich foods throughout the day.
That's where protein powder can be useful.
I use it myself, although I have to admit I've yet to find one I particularly enjoy drinking. My solution is to sprinkle a little chocolate protein powder over my morning porridge!
Protein powder isn't inherently better than food, and a small sprinkle won't provide the protein of a full serving. But it can be a convenient way to increase your intake.
My verdict: If you're already getting enough protein from food, you probably don't need it. If you're struggling, it's a practical option.
4. Psyllium husk: The underrated fibre supplement
Psyllium husk might be the least glamorous supplement on this list, but it's one of the most interesting.
It's a soluble fibre that absorbs water and forms a gel in the digestive tract.
Research suggests it can help with constipation, lower LDL cholesterol and improve blood glucose control in some people.
That's particularly relevant because many adults don't get enough fibre in their diets.
You can increase your fibre intake through oats, beans, lentils, fruit, vegetables and wholegrains, but psyllium can be a useful addition.
Start with a small amount, increase gradually and always take it with plenty of water. It can also affect the absorption of some medicines, so check how to space your doses.
My verdict: A relatively inexpensive supplement with useful evidence behind it, particularly for people who need more soluble fibre.
Five supplements where my answer is: Maybe
5. Magnesium: Does it really help with sleep?
Magnesium is involved in hundreds of processes in the body, including nerve and muscle function, blood pressure regulation and maintaining a normal heart rhythm.
It's an essential mineral, but that doesn't automatically mean everyone needs to take a magnesium supplement.
Magnesium glycinate has become particularly popular for sleep.
Some small studies suggest magnesium supplementation may help certain people sleep better, but the overall evidence is still limited.
It's also worth checking which form of magnesium you're buying. Some formulations, particularly at higher doses, can have a laxative effect and cause diarrhoea.
My verdict: Potentially worth considering if you're struggling with sleep or have inadequate magnesium intake, but the evidence doesn't justify recommending it routinely to everyone.
6. Omega-3: Better from fish or supplements?
Omega-3 fatty acids are important for normal body function, including cardiovascular health.
The NHS recommends eating at least two portions of fish a week, including one portion of oily fish such as salmon, mackerel or sardines.
If you rarely eat fish, you might wonder whether an omega-3 supplement would help.
The evidence for benefits from omega-3 capsules in the general population is less convincing than the evidence supporting a healthy diet that includes fish.
If you're buying a supplement, check the actual quantities of EPA and DHA rather than just the total fish oil content.
A capsule labelled 1,000 mg fish oil may contain considerably less than 1,000 mg of EPA and DHA combined.
Algae-derived omega-3 supplements are an option for vegetarians and people who don't eat fish.
My verdict: Worth considering depending on your diet and individual health needs, but not an automatic recommendation for everyone.
7. Iron: Particularly relevant during perimenopause
Iron deficiency is an important issue for women, particularly during perimenopause when periods can become heavier or more unpredictable.
Symptoms can include fatigue, breathlessness, palpitations, headaches and hair shedding.
Some women experience symptoms associated with low iron stores even before they develop anaemia.
Ferritin is a blood test that helps assess the body's iron stores. A result within the laboratory's reference range doesn't always exclude clinically relevant iron deficiency, particularly when symptoms and heavy menstrual bleeding are present.
Research suggests some non-anaemic women with fatigue and low ferritin can benefit from iron treatment, especially when ferritin is below approximately 50 micrograms per litre.
However, iron isn't something I'd recommend taking routinely without a reason.
My verdict: If you have symptoms or heavy periods, ask about testing for iron deficiency. Treatment can make a real difference when deficiency is present, but it's important to establish the cause.
8. Turmeric: Is there evidence for joint pain?
Turmeric contains curcumin, a compound that has been studied for its potential anti-inflammatory effects.
Some clinical trials suggest certain curcumin preparations may help reduce osteoarthritis pain.
However, results vary, and different supplements contain very different amounts and formulations of curcumin.
Concentrated turmeric and curcumin supplements can also cause side effects, interact with medicines and, rarely, have been associated with liver injury.
My verdict: There's enough research to make turmeric interesting, particularly for osteoarthritis, but not enough consistency for me to recommend it routinely.
9. Berberine: Is it really 'nature's Ozempic'?
Berberine is a plant-derived compound increasingly marketed for weight loss, blood sugar control and metabolic health.
It's sometimes described online as 'nature's Ozempic', but that's misleading.
The weight loss seen in studies of berberine is nowhere near what can be achieved with licensed GLP-1 weight-loss medicines.
However, research does suggest modest improvements in some metabolic measures, including blood glucose, LDL cholesterol, triglycerides and waist circumference.
The limitations are important. We don't have the same quality of long-term evidence, safety monitoring or standardisation that we'd expect from a licensed medicine.
Berberine can also interact with other medications.
My verdict: Interesting research, but not a replacement for proven treatments and not something I'd recommend simply because of its weight-loss marketing.
Three supplements I wouldn't spend my money on at the moment
10. Collagen: Does it really improve ageing skin?
Collagen supplements are heavily marketed to women who want to improve skin hydration, elasticity and wrinkles.
Some studies have reported positive results.
However, a 2025 meta-analysis of 23 randomised trials raised important questions about the quality of the evidence.
Although the overall results suggested benefits, those benefits were no longer statistically significant when researchers examined higher-quality studies and studies without pharmaceutical-company funding separately.
That makes me cautious about recommending an expensive supplement on the strength of the headline findings.
My verdict: I'm not convinced there's sufficiently strong independent evidence to justify spending money on collagen specifically for younger-looking skin.
For protecting skin from premature ageing, I'd prioritise daily sun protection.
11. Ashwagandha: Natural doesn't always mean safe
Ashwagandha is a herbal supplement marketed for stress, anxiety, sleep and cortisol regulation.
Some small studies suggest certain preparations may improve stress or sleep, but the evidence remains limited.
More importantly, there are safety considerations that aren't always obvious from the marketing.
Ashwagandha may interact with medicines, and there are particular concerns for people with thyroid disorders.
Rare cases of serious liver injury have also been reported, including liver failure, transplantation and deaths. Some of the most severe outcomes have occurred in people with underlying liver disease.
These events appear to be very uncommon, but they're important when weighing up the potential benefits and risks.
My verdict: Given the current evidence and safety concerns, it's not a supplement I'd recommend routinely for stress or sleep.
12. Pumpkin seed oil: Does it help menopausal hair loss?
Pumpkin seed oil has attracted attention as a possible treatment for hair thinning.
There is some preliminary research, including a small study involving women with female-pattern hair loss.
However, the evidence is far too limited to establish it as an effective treatment.
Hair loss around menopause can have several causes, including female-pattern hair loss, iron deficiency and thyroid problems.
Identifying the cause is more useful than simply trying supplements.
My verdict: I wouldn't currently recommend pumpkin seed oil as an evidence-based treatment for menopausal hair loss.
I've also made a short video on my Dr Sophie Lifestyle YouTube channel covering the different treatment options for hair loss around menopause.
What about supplements marketed specifically for menopause?
There's a whole industry devoted to supplements for women in perimenopause and menopause.
Products may contain combinations of vitamins, minerals and herbal ingredients such as black cohosh, red clover, sage and isoflavones.
Some of these ingredients have been studied for menopausal symptoms, but the evidence varies considerably.
A Which? investigation of 26 supplements marketed to women in midlife identified more than 80 different active ingredients across the products.
Some were remarkably expensive. One would cost approximately £468 per year despite containing relatively small amounts of common nutrients, while some supplement packages cost more than £1,000 annually.
An expensive menopause-branded supplement isn't necessarily more effective than a basic product containing the same nutrients.
And not every woman needs a multivitamin either.
Herbal ingredients can also have side effects and interact with prescribed medication.
I'll be covering the evidence behind individual menopause supplements, including black cohosh, red clover and sage, in a separate video.
Which supplements should a woman over 40 actually take?
The answer depends on what you're trying to achieve.
Rather than starting with the question, 'Which supplements should I be taking now I'm over 40?', I'd suggest asking:
'What am I trying to improve, and is a supplement the best way to achieve it?'
If you're struggling to get enough protein, protein powder might help.
If you're strength training, creatine may offer additional benefits.
If you have heavy periods and low iron stores, treating iron deficiency could make a significant difference.
If you're not getting enough fibre, psyllium might be useful.
And if you live in the UK, vitamin D is worth considering during autumn and winter in line with national guidance.
But there's no good evidence that every woman needs an expensive daily collection of supplements simply because she's entered perimenopause.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best supplements for women over 40?
There isn't a single combination that's best for everyone. Vitamin D is recommended for consideration during autumn and winter in the UK. Creatine may benefit women doing resistance training, protein powder can help when dietary protein is inadequate, and psyllium husk can support fibre intake and cholesterol management.
Should women over 40 take magnesium every day?
Not necessarily. Magnesium is essential for health, but most people should aim to obtain it from food. Evidence that routine magnesium supplementation improves sleep in otherwise healthy adults remains limited.
Is creatine safe for women during menopause?
Creatine monohydrate has been extensively studied and is generally well tolerated by healthy adults at recommended doses. Women with kidney disease or other significant medical conditions should seek individual advice before taking it.
Does collagen help menopausal skin?
Some trials report improvements in skin hydration and elasticity, but concerns about study quality and funding mean the evidence is less convincing than it initially appears. Better independent research is needed.
Can supplements replace HRT during menopause?
Supplements should not be assumed to provide the same benefits as evidence-based menopause treatments. Some herbal products have been investigated for symptom relief, but effectiveness and safety vary. Women experiencing troublesome symptoms should discuss their treatment options with a qualified healthcare professional.
The bottom line
Supplements can have a useful role in women's health after 40, but their value depends on your diet, symptoms, health conditions and goals.
Some have convincing evidence for particular uses. Others have promising but incomplete research. And some are marketed far more enthusiastically than the evidence justifies.
The most useful question isn't whether a supplement is popular, natural or marketed for menopause.
It's whether there's a good reason for you to take it.
Watch my video on this topic here:
Have a health question you'd like answered? Leave it in the comments on my YouTube channel. I choose topics for my Ask Sophie videos from the questions women send me.
This article provides general health information and is not a substitute for personalised medical advice. Supplements can interact with medicines and may not be suitable for everyone.